Pre Employment Screening & Validation Services

The Granary,
East Lenham Farm, Ashford Road,
Lenham, Kent. ME17 2DP

Tel: 01622 817580
Fax: 01622 813675

Secure Screening Logins

Applicant Login

Client Login

Criminal Records Checks "Arbitrary" and Unlawful

R (on the application of P) v. Secretary of State for Justice [2016] All ER (D) 166 (Jan)
The High Court has upheld a challenge by way of judicial review to the criminal records disclosure scheme used in England and Wales. It has found the scheme to be "arbitrary" and disproportionate, and it was ruled unlawful, as incompatible with Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
Under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974, convictions, cautions, reprimands and warnings become "spent" after a certain period of time. However, in certain "excepted positions" (principally those working with children or vulnerable adults) the general rule does not apply and all prior convictions must be disclosed, however old or trivial, where there has been more than one previous conviction. The focus of the challenge was on this exception.
Both claimants in the case had multiple minor historic criminal offences recorded against them – one during a period where the applicant was suffering from an undiagnosed mental health condition and the other for offences which were over 30 years old. Both claimants had no subsequent convictions but were still required to disclose their historic convictions under the current scheme. The claimants argued that this was affecting their ability to find employment and impacted on their Article 8 rights.
Article 8 provides that:
everyone has the right to respect for his private and family life, his home and his correspondence; and
there shall be no interference by a public authority with the exercise of this right except such as is in accordance with the law and is necessary in a democratic society in the interest of national security, public safety or the economic well-being of the country, for the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals, or for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others.
The High Court found that setting the bar at any more than one single conviction is arbitrary and neither in accordance with the law nor proportionate within the second limb of the test set out in Article 8.2 (as argued by the defendants).
The court has asked the government to make submissions to address the faults in the statutory scheme, before it makes its final order. The criminal records disclosure scheme will continue to run in its current form until this final order is made. The Home Office is considering whether there may be grounds to seek leave to appeal the decision.
Affected employers will not need to make any changes to their criminal records checks processes until the final order is made. However, they may wish to take preparatory steps in anticipation of the changes to the law, which are inevitable in light of the High Court's judgment. This may involve employers having extra regard to information on DBS certificates (particularly where convictions may be considered minor or occurred a long time ago) and making a reasonable assessment of whether a prospective employee should be discounted simply on the basis of minor past convictions.
Employers may also wish to take stock of how robust their current background checks and pre-employment processes are, and consider whether any modifications would be beneficial.

Current News

Supreme Court rejects government appeal on criminal records scheme

Man acquitted of rape loses Supreme Court criminal check case

Criminal record check for Tier 2 UK migrants

New guidance for job applicants implemented in drug and alcohol workplace policy

Right to work checks: Extended criminal liabilities for employers

Criminal Records Checks "Arbitrary" and Unlawful

The Emergence of Continuous Screening: Moving Background Screening From Pre-hire Problem Identification to a Threat Management Tool that Helps to Mitigate Risk

FINRA’s New Background Investigation Rule

Woman Sentenced To Prison For Fingerprint Fraud

Everybody Talks: Data Protection and Social Media

DBS filtering on criminal record certificates

UK financial regulation overhauled

The City's new watchdogs: what you need to know

Employment law 2013: progress on reform

What changes to criminal record checks are coming into effect from September 2012?

Olympic security chaos: depth of G4S security crisis revealed

Yahoo CEO steps down after CV embarrassment

Get Out of My Face(book)! When Pre-Employment Screening Goes Too Far

Social Media use: Issues for employers

Employment Law reforms announced

Court of Appeal guidance on references

Anti-bribery and corruption laws - an international guide

Loss of 26,000 housing records highlights poor state of UK data protection

UK Bribery Act Guidance: Muddy[ing] the Waters

Fake identities makes couple thousands

CBI calls for lower taxes in an 'all-action' Budget

HSBC bats down talk of a move to Hong Kong as it 'prefers the City'

Police chief 'lied on CV'

Radical shake-up of the Criminal Record regime and vetting and barring scheme.

Extra Pay Disclosure for the Four Largest Banks - More to Follow for Other Large Banks?

Workplace Disputes and Employer’s Charter

Comprehensive Spending Review: Job cuts 'will create new North/South divide'

Employment Law changes on 1st October 2010

FSA-Changes to the Remuneration Code

Financial sector pay - the latest instalment

Employment Law under the New Coalition Government

Employment Changes from April 2010

Proposed Reduction of the Gender Pay Gap at European Level

Jefferson Hunt Limited joins International membership of NAPBS (National Association of Professional Background Screeners)

Fraud: honesty is the best policy

CV lies and interview technique | The Apprentice

Pre-employment screening as a critical risk-management tool

Exposed: the fakers behind the CV masks

Industry Quotes

“more than 7.5 million of Britain's 25.3 million working population have misled their potential employer while applying for a job.”

Mori .

Quote of the Week

“"I love those who can smile in trouble, who can gather strength from distress, and grow brave by reflection. 'Tis the business of little minds to shrink, but they whose heart is firm, and whose conscience approves their conduct, will pursue their principles unto death." .”

Industry Sectors

Screening Levels

  National Association of Professional Background Screeners
© Copyright 2017 JH Ltd   Tel: 01622 817580   Email:

Site Map     Privacy Policy     Terms & Conditions